Source / pinned edition

Auli Gellii Noctium Atticarum liber V, caput X

Source of package la.gellius.protagoras_euathlus · Gell. NA V.10

work: urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NOCTES_ATTICAE_V_10
number: Gell. NA V.10
kind: urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#doctrine

Vicifons, Noctes Atticae/Liber V, recensio 269232

edition: urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS
language: la
officiality: unofficial
materialisation: PINNED_UNOFFICIAL_COPY
life cycle: adopted: 1000-01-01; in_force: [object Object]

Publications

URI	Type	documentHash	Retrieved
https://la.wikisource.org/w/index.php?oldid=269232&action=raw	text/plain; charset=utf-8	sha256:3f697d5b25c5ac2241a7fa72f8fc0f37a6787d5f4c1529d9e43721aa1b9a1451	2026-08-30T10:00:00Z

Fragments — 16

article/1 · paragraph · referenced by: 1

la · official · sha256:ca6f88f3ccdf2f6f3d5560e158dd02f692c96d8154d07194024c825cbed83321LA

Inter vitia argumentorum longe maximum esse vitium videtur, quae antistrephonta Graeci dicunt.

Referencing norms: VitiumMaximum

article/10 · paragraph · referenced by: 26

la · official · sha256:bb5e3dcd9cda692eac1388c30576289ac69854ea33004317934cce1a02ad13eaLA

Nam si contra te lis data erit, merces mihi ex sententia tia debebitur, quia ego vicero; sin vero secundum te iudicatum erit, merces mihi ex pacto debebitur, quia tu viceris.”

Referencing norms: Controversia, Controversia/ActaApudIudices, Controversia/AdIudicesVenire, Controversia/Contestata, Controversia/Differre, Controversia/Dilata, Controversia/IudicatumProDiscipulo, Controversia/IudicatumProMagistro, Controversia/PronuntiareProDiscipulo, Controversia/PronuntiareProMagistro, ControversiaState, ControversiaStep, ControversiaTransition, ExPactoDebebitur, ExSententiaDebebitur, SententiaeParendum, SententiaeParere, VictoriaIudicata, attempted_transition, current_state, entered_state, initial_state, left_state, procedure_instance, state_before, valid_transition

article/11 · paragraph · referenced by: 2

la · official · sha256:32ad0954bb8cd26577b785ab84c7745d44e7fcaaf393362871ff3820eae79061LA

Ad ea respondit Evathlus: “Potui” inquit “huic tuae tam ancipiti captioni isse obviam, si verba non ipse facerem atque alio patrono uterer.

Referencing norms: IpseOravit, assert-hb680552eff204893689a1831ef4075a0e5f38a3cf96016cdad1c20c2d609ec14

article/12 · paragraph · referenced by: 1

la · official · sha256:0e599994962d71a34e742df2c48a7cb40ce3277cf70642944af4e9edb08f6620LA

Sed maius mihi in ista victoria prolubium est, cum te non in causa tantum, sed in argumento quoque isto vinco.

Referencing norms: assert-h355aca052bad5ecebf3ebdcb0684a87b608a3c803ac1a744b74824b8cc613cf0

article/13 · paragraph · referenced by: 4

la · official · sha256:694ba2b1e465bd6e7f1d8ad9828bb42e99dee355f5db085fa81bb697908086fdLA

Disce igitur tu quoque, magister sapientissime, utroque modo fore, uti non reddam, quod petis, sive contra me pronuntiatum fuerit sive pro me.

Referencing norms: ARGUMENTUM_EVATHLI, ExPactoNihilDebebitur, ExSententiaNihilDebebitur, assert-he4f365e4b94b43452f492ab2851aec3dc448714a63a70149d7fadcb4b4fac1da

article/14 · paragraph · referenced by: 25

la · official · sha256:66fd7df606bf336dcd161c19e32ccf9dd5999601f917105a56c948e63fc03373LA

Nam si iudices pro causa mea senserint, nihil tibi ex sententia debebitur, quia ego vicero; sin contra me pronuntiaverint, nihil tibi ex pacto debebo, quia non vicero.”

Referencing norms: Controversia, Controversia/ActaApudIudices, Controversia/AdIudicesVenire, Controversia/Contestata, Controversia/Differre, Controversia/Dilata, Controversia/IudicatumProDiscipulo, Controversia/IudicatumProMagistro, Controversia/PronuntiareProDiscipulo, Controversia/PronuntiareProMagistro, ControversiaState, ControversiaStep, ControversiaTransition, ExPactoNihilDebebitur, ExSententiaNihilDebebitur, SententiaeParendum, SententiaeParere, attempted_transition, current_state, entered_state, initial_state, left_state, procedure_instance, state_before, valid_transition

article/15 · paragraph · referenced by: 22

la · official · sha256:a6f3391281444e9b4afbb6548396097ba1487d1e4098715dd8b30a7935c656a2LA

Tum iudices dubiosum hoc inexplicabileque esse, quod utrimque dicebatur, rati, ne sententia sua, utramcumque in partem dicta esset, ipsa sese rescinderet, rem iniudicatam reliquerunt causamque in diem longissimam distulerunt.

Referencing norms: Controversia, Controversia/ActaApudIudices, Controversia/AdIudicesVenire, Controversia/Contestata, Controversia/Differre, Controversia/Dilata, Controversia/IudicatumProDiscipulo, Controversia/IudicatumProMagistro, Controversia/PronuntiareProDiscipulo, Controversia/PronuntiareProMagistro, ControversiaState, ControversiaStep, ControversiaTransition, attempted_transition, current_state, entered_state, initial_state, left_state, procedure_instance, res_iniudicata_relicta, state_before, valid_transition

article/16 · paragraph · referenced by: 1

la · official · sha256:ea1da4233e8b0ad74de029ddcd1c13474dc3003ee39a23588112a526ad5b1f9fLA

Sic ab adulescente discipulo magister eloquentiae inclutus suo sibi argumento confutatus est et captionis versute excogitatae frustratus fuit.

Referencing norms: ConfutatioAuctoris

article/2 · paragraph · referenced by: 1

la · official · sha256:527b89a987d85eb461b3415d223f230440f24364f3f53064d2fdda1e59da17b4LA

Ea quidam e nostris non hercle nimis absurde “reciproca” appellaverunt.

Referencing norms: argumentum_reciprocum

article/3 · paragraph · referenced by: 2

la · official · sha256:6368820086fe12935187fabec1b72f11562663b9c5b45b1ff4ada7fea257c0f3LA

Id autem vitium accidit hoc modo, cum argumentum propositum referri contra convertique in eum potest, a quo dictum est, et utrimque pariter valet; quale est pervolgatum illud, quo Protagoram, sophistarum acerrimum, usum esse ferunt adversus Evathlum, discipulum suum.

Referencing norms: Antistrephon, argumentum_reciprocum

article/4 · paragraph · referenced by: 1

la · official · sha256:a0e58bb4f207823e6a4f5c0f518b6367e936f646cc7ec1f41ee303d0bc417c72LA

Lis namque inter eos et controversia super pacta mercede haec fuit.

Referencing norms: lis_contestata

article/5 · paragraph · referenced by: 1

la · official · sha256:1f4f2b735dca836d3cec3c73defe40de7cee05cc12ade219a9a69aff4dcb17e2LA

Evathlus, adulescens dives, eloquentiae discendae causarumque orandi cupiens fuit.

Referencing norms: assert-h405f3a7542129aedae3e4aa18ca99a055de32dff67307c9051670d9da720c1cf

article/6 · paragraph · referenced by: 7

la · official · sha256:89dbcc3fc38c20b77a20ab9adc523be0e9efa10f3b35301e2732369215dc5a99LA

Is in disciplinam Protagorae sese dedit daturumque promisit mercedem grandem pecuniam, quantam Protagoras petiverat, dimidiumque eius dedit iam tunc statim, priusquam disceret, pepigitque, ut relicum dimidium daret, quo primo die causam apud iudices orasset et vicisset.

Referencing norms: MercesExPacto, PrimaVictoria, ReliquumDare, ReliquumSolvendum, assert-h87cc7f8dd2a89e0e253fabec715303dfdad17d0eb38edfbed01486369e388760, assert-h8a3dd70c078fd0c4601dae51032b5d97f119df43fdaf0a9a0fe5e28392c0e704, assert-hb220e4a02bbced3bad41138f51276f45b18b220a49a1ac7b36c34596da1df260

article/7 · paragraph · referenced by: 1

la · official · sha256:dfdfddf14db725320ebcaf4d09c1fd59d9324f0084b9fc4adaa210a851a65a4aLA

Postea cum diutule auditor adsectatorque Protagorae fuisset et in studio quidem facundiae abunde promovisset, causas tamen non reciperet tempusque iam longum transcurreret et facere id videretur, ne relicum mercedis daret, capit consilium Protagoras, ut tum existimabat, astutum:

Referencing norms: assert-hc8780c05e22bc27209cfbb9b08a4000b43cabd4ba785d9c699150634315c3d78

article/8 · paragraph · referenced by: 22

la · official · sha256:8649947537595e80ca2fbdb1708436abf5e7ed16d0301d33ee7daa53854837e1LA

petere institit ex pacto mercedem, litem cum Evathlo contestatur.

Referencing norms: Controversia, Controversia/ActaApudIudices, Controversia/AdIudicesVenire, Controversia/Contestata, Controversia/Differre, Controversia/Dilata, Controversia/IudicatumProDiscipulo, Controversia/IudicatumProMagistro, Controversia/PronuntiareProDiscipulo, Controversia/PronuntiareProMagistro, ControversiaState, ControversiaStep, ControversiaTransition, attempted_transition, current_state, entered_state, initial_state, left_state, lis_contestata, procedure_instance, state_before, valid_transition

article/9 · paragraph · referenced by: 28

la · official · sha256:c6f12aa15fccf5ddf9e9a3156f3996f7db42ab0868f78011091b1f7104dac5deLA

Et cum ad iudices coniciendae consistendaeque causae gratia venissent, tum Protagoras sic exorsus est: “Disce,” inquit “stultissime adulescens, utroque id modo fore, uti reddas, quod peto, sive contra te pronuntiatum erit sive pro te.

Referencing norms: ARGUMENTUM_PROTAGORAE, Controversia, Controversia/ActaApudIudices, Controversia/AdIudicesVenire, Controversia/Contestata, Controversia/Differre, Controversia/Dilata, Controversia/IudicatumProDiscipulo, Controversia/IudicatumProMagistro, Controversia/PronuntiareProDiscipulo, Controversia/PronuntiareProMagistro, ControversiaState, ControversiaStep, ControversiaTransition, ExPactoDebebitur, ExSententiaDebebitur, VictoriaIudicata, assert-h04f2f1493f1b40ffe93e0397e15dae288db4c104df6a16c0b4057775d52eaf11, attempted_transition, current_state, entered_state, initial_state, left_state, procedure_instance, pronuntiatum_pro, pronuntiatum_pro/external, state_before, valid_transition

The hash beside the text is the sha256 of its exact bytes. It is the check that the text shown matches the one pinned in the package: a divergence fails the oracle’s static analysis.