{"features":["core-executable"],"imports":[],"metadata":{"localSources":{"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_TEXT":"sources/protagoras-euathlus/la.txt"}},"nodes":[{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_13"],"contentHash":"sha256:7d54d604d0cd0dac955f7bf43b9158c61dbdd5bdef2f4be881662dea21c6f99c","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ARGUMENTUM_EVATHLI","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"argumentum Evathli: utroque modo fore, uti non reddam"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"довод Еватла: не заплачу при любом исходе"}],"name":"ARGUMENTUM_EVATHLI","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Argumentum"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ArgumentumEvathli","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9"],"contentHash":"sha256:e8259ea00573a316de317794a971f416e5e31ec613c5e22efb7aedabad3e1afc","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ARGUMENTUM_PROTAGORAE","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"argumentum Protagorae: utroque modo fore, uti reddas"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"довод Протагора: заплатишь при любом исходе"}],"name":"ARGUMENTUM_PROTAGORAE","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Argumentum"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ArgumentumProtagorae","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:bee32f2a54396c830275177e8a3c2a1690b7d14df4a0ba7174794a0afbd3f43c","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ActaApudIudices","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"ad iudices venerunt, causa agitur (V.10.9)"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"стороны перед судьями, дело слушается"}],"name":"ActaApudIudices","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaState"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ActaApudIudices","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:44940ef3621cfddfa60ae064a66df9963e3bfd16f82d3c961208f0d86a9acd2a","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#AdIudicesVenire","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.9. ad iudices coniciendae consistendaeque causae gratia venerunt"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.9. Стороны явились к судьям, дело слушается"}],"name":"AdIudicesVenire","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaTransition"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#AdIudicesVenire","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_3"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#dictum_ab"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#utrimque_pariter_valet"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#converti_potest_in_auctorem"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:022219560cf8aeec3ba71fd4a27fa72031deef1394c0ab84a2c6628c5f341a76","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#argumentum_reciprocum"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Antistrephon","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"cum argumentum referri contra convertique in eum potest, a quo dictum est, et utrimque pariter valet"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"довод оборачиваем, если может быть обращён против автора и стоит одинаково сильно с обеих сторон"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Argumentum"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:6919f86b5e1f4a966aa06ca96e5b41d0bb68bca2735a353f143105c9a2ae6e13","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Argumentum","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"argumentum propositum"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"выдвинутый довод"}],"name":"Argumentum","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","typeKind":"entity"},{"contentHash":"sha256:02768307623f5a40f26785ac81d98abd86b07e97e02bea7462df307638b49749","excludes":[],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#CaptioEvathli","includes":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ExPactoNihilDebebitur","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ExSententiaNihilDebebitur"],"kind":"interpretation","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"captio Evathli: utroque modo fore, uti non reddam"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"Прочтение Еватла: не заплачу при любом исходе"}],"of":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14"],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","status":"disputed"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0e2c26f2d4aa28481a8729f4ca3e05eb4054a4f982ab434814c20801394f60a4","excludes":[],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#CaptioProtagorae","includes":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ExPactoDebebitur","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ExSententiaDebebitur"],"kind":"interpretation","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"captio Protagorae: utroque modo fore, uti reddas"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"Прочтение Протагора: заплатишь при любом исходе"}],"of":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10"],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","status":"disputed"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_16"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#argumentum_reciprocum"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#dictum_ab"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:7f530f4c5ada9be7f38e1b134c5f9b924f2c9342a606fc84097297e431444e13","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#suo_argumento_confutatus"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ConfutatioAuctoris","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"suo sibi argumento confutatus est et captionis versute excogitatae frustratus fuit"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"автор оборачиваемого довода опровергнут собственным доводом"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Argumentum"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:3da4603898fc6f451fd44d4bed678c44e6a2436ce6019506053ab21f6239b7bc","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Contestata","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"lis contestata est (V.10.8)"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"иск предъявлен"}],"name":"Contestata","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaState"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Contestata","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"body":{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#AdIudicesVenire","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#valid_transition"},"kind":"status","status":"supported"},"contentHash":"sha256:97cece63123c1e49db121b59e92ce8ccebea7232502276727fb408c67b959dbd","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ActaApudIudices","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Controversia/AdIudicesVenire/enters","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.9. ad iudices coniciendae consistendaeque causae gratia venerunt"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.9. Стороны явились к судьям, дело слушается"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#AdIudicesVenire","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#attempted_transition"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Contestata","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state"},"kind":"status","status":"supported"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causa_acta_apud_iudices"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:9773e730d898798a04fad9cde3302a8d00d212c4e60ae0cebbaf34b391119bcb","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#AdIudicesVenire","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#valid_transition"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Controversia/AdIudicesVenire/valid","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.9. ad iudices coniciendae consistendaeque causae gratia venerunt"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.9. Стороны явились к судьям, дело слушается"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"body":{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Differre","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#valid_transition"},"kind":"status","status":"supported"},"contentHash":"sha256:6937238af5b39c0d281e00e3bfbd98e10bfbf00b1a32c5b3a7f45d9c548ca1cc","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Dilata","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Controversia/Differre/enters","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.15. rem iniudicatam reliquerunt causamque in diem longissimam distulerunt"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.15. Судьи оставили дело нерассуженным и отложили его"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Differre","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#attempted_transition"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ActaApudIudices","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state"},"kind":"status","status":"supported"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#res_iniudicata_relicta"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:53fd85e4a901f04b4d3f5b2edfcceaee110bedd29091477efca4d28b9462bb04","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Differre","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#valid_transition"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Controversia/Differre/valid","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.15. rem iniudicatam reliquerunt causamque in diem longissimam distulerunt"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.15. Судьи оставили дело нерассуженным и отложили его"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"body":{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PronuntiareProDiscipulo","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#valid_transition"},"kind":"status","status":"supported"},"contentHash":"sha256:e8cb7afdbf92c3cc4ddf877fb19ff5f6b4a98de480c296a1a155428fd220f9cd","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#IudicatumProDiscipulo","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Controversia/PronuntiareProDiscipulo/enters","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.14. si iudices pro causa mea senserint"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.14. Приговор вынесен в пользу ученика"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PronuntiareProDiscipulo","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#attempted_transition"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ActaApudIudices","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state"},"kind":"status","status":"supported"},{"formula":{"args":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#EVATHLUS","kind":"const_ref"},{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pronuntiatum_pro"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:7d940f31aa51c662ab5833a146b1d50c649a1498bc5174bc3786f9806a771dfb","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PronuntiareProDiscipulo","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#valid_transition"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Controversia/PronuntiareProDiscipulo/valid","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.14. si iudices pro causa mea senserint"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.14. Приговор вынесен в пользу ученика"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"body":{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PronuntiareProMagistro","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#valid_transition"},"kind":"status","status":"supported"},"contentHash":"sha256:fbafc3292bce2e5760ba5d2b73433e59306613bee9cd17ed13e6e04a57329cbe","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#IudicatumProMagistro","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Controversia/PronuntiareProMagistro/enters","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.10. si contra te lis data erit"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.10. Приговор вынесен в пользу учителя"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PronuntiareProMagistro","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#attempted_transition"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ActaApudIudices","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state"},"kind":"status","status":"supported"},{"formula":{"args":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PROTAGORAS","kind":"const_ref"},{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pronuntiatum_pro"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:1381a10ec1e04ccb648ac87b5859ee5ca652ee46b755440f40fa578df5f7e5f9","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PronuntiareProMagistro","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#valid_transition"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Controversia/PronuntiareProMagistro/valid","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.10. si contra te lis data erit"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.10. Приговор вынесен в пользу учителя"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"body":{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#procedure_instance"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},"contentHash":"sha256:8796e490a1f7f1a37eb523b9d1aa6d0265e81a60134a7c3c1a1e4e71b5cddd1b","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Contestata","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Controversia/initial","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"lis contestata est (V.10.8)"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"иск предъявлен"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:911b9e04ffe32e2a110e1c6e5041b6c5e0c98681d8e1b9c818d15173739d86a7","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaState","kind":"type_decl","name":"ControversiaState","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","typeKind":"entity"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:0238dd23018a1b829f0c336c3cd95a0053b029ec0d8092a55ab85363ccb000a3","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaTransition","kind":"type_decl","name":"ControversiaTransition","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","typeKind":"entity"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:16fc5ce25c513ec71f5316b91fd5721a9da45357f4a3c8ff64eab68582d905a3","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Differre","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.15. rem iniudicatam reliquerunt causamque in diem longissimam distulerunt"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.15. Судьи оставили дело нерассуженным и отложили его"}],"name":"Differre","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaTransition"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Differre","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:2af0163297071589d2bf544bc810494d051476ceaaa2a35ab2b21bf1985d1b32","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Dilata","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"res iniudicata relicta, causa in diem longissimam dilata (V.10.15)"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"дело оставлено нерассуженным и отложено"}],"name":"Dilata","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaState"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Dilata","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"contentHash":"sha256:4c357d7d464993664456149d108dfd9bc7ba6fbd77ca7ae321dbfc15aaebb0d8","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#EVATHLUS","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"Evathlus, adulescens dives, discipulus"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"Еватл, юноша богатый, ученик"}],"name":"EVATHLUS","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Evathlus","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v3"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pactum_mercedis"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_contestata"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#victoria"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:7158ddedc909dcf70e91f45bfa110ffae1379fd154128d498d9f44672dbfc1a5","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_debetur"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ExPactoDebebitur","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"sin vero secundum te iudicatum erit, merces mihi ex pacto debebitur, quia tu viceris"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"Протагор, вторая ветвь: решат в твою пользу — платишь по договору, ведь ты выиграл"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"defeasible","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}},{"id":"v3","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Pactum"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_13","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v3"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pactum_mercedis"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_contestata"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#victoria"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:81361432c3dec9cb7f43790e22d07dd65af5478d9a3186d84133fcb88dc420a9","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_debetur"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ExPactoNihilDebebitur","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"sin contra me pronuntiaverint, nihil tibi ex pacto debebo, quia non vicero"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"Еватл, вторая ветвь: решат против меня — по договору ничего не должен, ведь я не выиграл"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"defeasible","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}},{"id":"v3","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Pactum"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v3"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pactum_mercedis"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_contestata"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#victoria"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:6ef4187e98949cecf64c353a0e314dbee1c2917751cc59011cb917d89b2ee9d8","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_debetur"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ExSententiaDebebitur","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"si contra te lis data erit, merces mihi ex sententia debebitur, quia ego vicero"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"Протагор, первая ветвь: решат против тебя — платишь по приговору"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"defeasible","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}},{"id":"v3","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Pactum"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_13","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v3"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pactum_mercedis"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_contestata"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#victoria"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:509bf8509217c7a623d1c76e4afd8c9358db7ceb9f32387b4bbd57e888f10230","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_debetur"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ExSententiaNihilDebebitur","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"si iudices pro causa mea senserint, nihil tibi ex sententia debebitur, quia ego vicero"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"Еватл, первая ветвь: решат в мою пользу — по приговору ничего не должен"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"defeasible","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}},{"id":"v3","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Pactum"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_11"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causa_acta_apud_iudices"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_contestata"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ipse_verba_fecit"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:c6c81a73c4896207188f108266e99c9cddd418cd0e8d97b1dd7f818d446ed5f0","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causam_oravit"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#IpseOravit","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"verba ipse fecit, alio patrono non usus"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"говоривший сам произнёс дело в слушавшейся тяжбе"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:7ddf47c0dacce212491ba3fd154b2bb8bfb50a990d9cbe04add77225bd1a4f39","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#IudicatumProDiscipulo","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"secundum discipulum iudicatum est (V.10.14)"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"приговор в пользу ученика"}],"name":"IudicatumProDiscipulo","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaState"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#IudicatumProDiscipulo","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:a34e2764137ca5ea8158e063f443118c76cdf7ae08a647fc9596fab1e7edcb33","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#IudicatumProMagistro","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"contra discipulum pronuntiatum est (V.10.10)"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"приговор в пользу учителя"}],"name":"IudicatumProMagistro","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaState"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#IudicatumProMagistro","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"contentHash":"sha256:c9a7cb75bab101899844d4a785c4f714e5578d2d0a7d74dd54be79d10363570f","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"lis: controversia apud iudices acta"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"тяжба, ведомая перед судьями"}],"name":"Lis","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","typeKind":"entity"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_6"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v3"},{"kind":"var","var":"v4"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_prior"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v4"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_contestata"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pactum_mercedis"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v3"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#vicit_primam_causam"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:1c9b3fa43d4bf7c8f9b6d33e780e11643cb3f959066804e12e1f84c2823555fd","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_debetur"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#MercesExPacto","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"ut relicum dimidium daret"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"по договору остаток платы причитается, если первая победа одержана в ПРЕЖНЕЙ тяжбе"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Pactum"}},{"id":"v3","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}},{"id":"v4","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:0d330fc693edfd4e34162d439efe6e7e06eabc6cdc0648b845b4dfd3909337d8","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_1","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/1","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:ca6f88f3ccdf2f6f3d5560e158dd02f692c96d8154d07194024c825cbed83321","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Inter vitia argumentorum longe maximum esse vitium videtur, quae antistrephonta Graeci dicunt."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:98f4f2ad77c440de0596a95d1369c7369dd99d8a07f30a850a93347ebfba58a6","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/10","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:bb5e3dcd9cda692eac1388c30576289ac69854ea33004317934cce1a02ad13ea","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Nam si contra te lis data erit, merces mihi ex sententia tia debebitur, quia ego vicero; sin vero secundum te iudicatum erit, merces mihi ex pacto debebitur, quia tu viceris.”"}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:925c09c4560822905b0ff8d08a24a82509f3aa948d3f3baa60b8429606cb688c","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_11","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/11","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:32ad0954bb8cd26577b785ab84c7745d44e7fcaaf393362871ff3820eae79061","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Ad ea respondit Evathlus: “Potui” inquit “huic tuae tam ancipiti captioni isse obviam, si verba non ipse facerem atque alio patrono uterer."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:6aacd2efded735e83d5f44e2ddf4ef4a3c95f01cf7def24122f33f8aa82515cb","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_12","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/12","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:0e599994962d71a34e742df2c48a7cb40ce3277cf70642944af4e9edb08f6620","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Sed maius mihi in ista victoria prolubium est, cum te non in causa tantum, sed in argumento quoque isto vinco."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:b855e2028b8e40ea10c2f50ab2a5dec800bac125c8f99370708deaed907afa50","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_13","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/13","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:694ba2b1e465bd6e7f1d8ad9828bb42e99dee355f5db085fa81bb697908086fd","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Disce igitur tu quoque, magister sapientissime, utroque modo fore, uti non reddam, quod petis, sive contra me pronuntiatum fuerit sive pro me."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:045823ca90b922c19a39ad387b4e3514e353b681ec1cf85f90acd5d7d957f2da","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/14","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:66fd7df606bf336dcd161c19e32ccf9dd5999601f917105a56c948e63fc03373","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Nam si iudices pro causa mea senserint, nihil tibi ex sententia debebitur, quia ego vicero; sin contra me pronuntiaverint, nihil tibi ex pacto debebo, quia non vicero.”"}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:4d6fe067242767b2d788fef649d1954d8d8d6408783ff9020d58ac8e11dd5077","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/15","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:a6f3391281444e9b4afbb6548396097ba1487d1e4098715dd8b30a7935c656a2","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Tum iudices dubiosum hoc inexplicabileque esse, quod utrimque dicebatur, rati, ne sententia sua, utramcumque in partem dicta esset, ipsa sese rescinderet, rem iniudicatam reliquerunt causamque in diem longissimam distulerunt."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:123066586ec6e439e1a27e9079af57167c535925a77beb9a7a81f32ad21bd18d","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_16","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/16","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:ea1da4233e8b0ad74de029ddcd1c13474dc3003ee39a23588112a526ad5b1f9f","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Sic ab adulescente discipulo magister eloquentiae inclutus suo sibi argumento confutatus est et captionis versute excogitatae frustratus fuit."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:ced19a7278fc8ae1e336ab234989167654ab684379f2bb440cb6d7c16e2d1939","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_2","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/2","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:527b89a987d85eb461b3415d223f230440f24364f3f53064d2fdda1e59da17b4","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Ea quidam e nostris non hercle nimis absurde “reciproca” appellaverunt."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:e1f1758bf48d5a0a17270908c0e9bdfe6dfec52047d7a70cae135e941c07f87e","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_3","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/3","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:6368820086fe12935187fabec1b72f11562663b9c5b45b1ff4ada7fea257c0f3","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Id autem vitium accidit hoc modo, cum argumentum propositum referri contra convertique in eum potest, a quo dictum est, et utrimque pariter valet; quale est pervolgatum illud, quo Protagoram, sophistarum acerrimum, usum esse ferunt adversus Evathlum, discipulum suum."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:6280eea877dfe05926263f0fc21c1da1f1b7f700c3870aaa5c55db0076c45e44","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_4","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/4","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:a0e58bb4f207823e6a4f5c0f518b6367e936f646cc7ec1f41ee303d0bc417c72","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Lis namque inter eos et controversia super pacta mercede haec fuit."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:d05eadff11fd7220b5100893934c60fc13f1314bae3e980d3fd172bf3c4d587a","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_5","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/5","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:1f4f2b735dca836d3cec3c73defe40de7cee05cc12ade219a9a69aff4dcb17e2","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Evathlus, adulescens dives, eloquentiae discendae causarumque orandi cupiens fuit."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:624d111cc0a6823498357379b6749c0ecf1661665be0609713c28b036a70030d","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_6","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/6","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:89dbcc3fc38c20b77a20ab9adc523be0e9efa10f3b35301e2732369215dc5a99","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Is in disciplinam Protagorae sese dedit daturumque promisit mercedem grandem pecuniam, quantam Protagoras petiverat, dimidiumque eius dedit iam tunc statim, priusquam disceret, pepigitque, ut relicum dimidium daret, quo primo die causam apud iudices orasset et vicisset."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:1c6768fe9c23601355105cae57359f3de16f0749a13b585929c5545b5dde6cdc","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_7","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/7","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:dfdfddf14db725320ebcaf4d09c1fd59d9324f0084b9fc4adaa210a851a65a4a","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Postea cum diutule auditor adsectatorque Protagorae fuisset et in studio quidem facundiae abunde promovisset, causas tamen non reciperet tempusque iam longum transcurreret et facere id videretur, ne relicum mercedis daret, capit consilium Protagoras, ut tum existimabat, astutum:"}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:2d1b16692090584e7759402f09c26046a4a08203283d09247f381085f63b5bf5","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/8","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:8649947537595e80ca2fbdb1708436abf5e7ed16d0301d33ee7daa53854837e1","language":"la","status":"official","text":"petere institit ex pacto mercedem, litem cum Evathlo contestatur."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:4f861270dfc15c1ba1a2f7f762392548fec86bcd187152de9c9c29b124d0ca37","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","fragmentKind":"paragraph","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/9","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:c6f12aa15fccf5ddf9e9a3156f3996f7db42ab0868f78011091b1f7104dac5de","language":"la","status":"official","text":"Et cum ad iudices coniciendae consistendaeque causae gratia venissent, tum Protagoras sic exorsus est: “Disce,” inquit “stultissime adulescens, utroque id modo fore, uti reddas, quod peto, sive contra te pronuntiatum erit sive pro te."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:c487f600124933096eb290410f23fcd7a1a5c6c464c63dc2c3c69c592af807ff","documentHash":"sha256:3f697d5b25c5ac2241a7fa72f8fc0f37a6787d5f4c1529d9e43721aa1b9a1451","edition":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_TEXT","kind":"publication","mediaType":"text/plain; charset=utf-8","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","retrievedAt":"2026-08-30T10:00:00Z","uri":"https://la.wikisource.org/w/index.php?oldid=269232&action=raw"},{"contentHash":"sha256:d4c6c17b9c528fa1cc4e1584e7b3b8600abb058f4387cb0e37bcc1eeac915420","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_VICIFONS","kind":"source_edition","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"Vicifons, Noctes Atticae/Liber V, recensio 269232"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"Латинская Викитека, ревизия 269232 (закреплена)"}],"language":"la","lifecycle":[{"extent":"1000-01-01","status":"adopted"},{"extent":{"axis":"legal_time","endInclusive":false,"start":"1000-01-01","startInclusive":true},"status":"in_force"}],"materializationStatus":"PINNED_UNOFFICIAL_COPY","officiality":"unofficial","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","work":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NOCTES_ATTICAE_V_10"},{"contentHash":"sha256:5510a46b39b54aa86a6defee285292451fb0f0f4473604a4476685012b078ce7","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NOCTES_ATTICAE_V_10","jurisdiction":{"kind":"value","type":{"name":"urn:law:std#Text"},"value":"none"},"kind":"source_work","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"Auli Gellii Noctium Atticarum liber V, caput X"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"Авл Геллий, «Аттические ночи», книга V, глава 10"}],"number":"Gell. NA V.10","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","sourceKind":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#doctrine"},{"contentHash":"sha256:6668dd2acd8d1196e75531a8500ea50c95f46150060cdfde35351a045956a805","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PACTUM_MERCEDIS","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"pactum de mercede grandi, dimidio statim dato"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"договор о большой плате: половина отдана сразу"}],"name":"PACTUM_MERCEDIS","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Pactum"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PactumMercedis","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"contentHash":"sha256:36cb591339a61f85a70fe0845e5e2ef9848d3caf5655421f56068e8e4ac0bba3","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PROTAGORAS","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"Protagoras, sophistarum acerrimus"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"Протагор, острейший из софистов"}],"name":"PROTAGORAS","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Protagoras","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"contentHash":"sha256:40948ae2d103d5c3d0e4fd788dddba01fdec4e349cfdb511ab6b5e6cf3f13873","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Pactum","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"pactum de mercede"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"договор о плате за обучение"}],"name":"Pactum","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","typeKind":"entity"},{"contentHash":"sha256:c159fe3582c3f90b27479de2d42521738b20ef7dbdb7dedd06d10a0d3c2c3ead","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"persona"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"лицо"}],"name":"Persona","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","typeKind":"entity"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_6"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causa_prima"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#victoria"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causam_oravit"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:777cbf8a70441da2a12c35fc1116ea06ed84f7a4f84dbcf7f78bbc5b177cc7cf","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#vicit_primam_causam"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PrimaVictoria","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"quo primo die causam apud iudices orasset et vicisset"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"первая победа: сам произнёс дело в первой своей тяжбе и выиграл её"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:374c9ba4555de2f438caacd7e3fe1ccd7f82a337d1f238308f28e82f57917d3b","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PronuntiareProDiscipulo","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.14. si iudices pro causa mea senserint"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.14. Приговор вынесен в пользу ученика"}],"name":"PronuntiareProDiscipulo","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaTransition"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PronuntiareProDiscipulo","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:5325491fbe420a7ce339791d9db5e0073e91351ddc913171cfa5235c81ab6355","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PronuntiareProMagistro","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"V.10.10. si contra te lis data erit"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"V.10.10. Приговор вынесен в пользу учителя"}],"name":"PronuntiareProMagistro","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[],"returnType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaTransition"},"symbolKind":"constant","value":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PronuntiareProMagistro","kind":"entity_ref"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_6"],"contentHash":"sha256:a2c497822fbdf3573e1d33ecf2a1f259dd21f4fb2a2c61f9ac1a9253fff970a0","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ReliquumDare","kind":"norm_template","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"relicum dimidium daret"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"должник обязан отдать остальную половину платы"}],"modality":"duty","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","payload":{"bearer":{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},"beneficiary":{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},"goal":{"condition":{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_reliqua_soluta"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},"kind":"achievement","window":{"end":{"kind":"value","type":{"name":"urn:law:std#Text"},"value":"infinity"},"endInclusive":false,"kind":"interval","start":{"kind":"value","type":{"name":"urn:law:std#Date"},"value":"0001-01-01"},"startInclusive":true}},"kind":"duty"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_6"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pactum_mercedis"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_debetur"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:c97dcc7412103c5bc8153f41ac43b34020e84521e20042bcaa0c1ca920384ee7","head":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ReliquumDare","kind":"norm_template_ref"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ReliquumSolvendum","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"relicum dimidium daret"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"должник обязан отдать остальную половину платы"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Pactum"}}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:b62bf286ae28bcad433bce8494138abc98b000d380ebb95817465feacd7ea58f","fields":[{"name":"pars","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"name":"lis","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#SententiaPetitio","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"petitio ut de lite pronuntietur"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"запрос о суждении: в чью пользу решена тяжба"}],"name":"SententiaPetitio","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","typeKind":"record"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14"],"body":{"items":[{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_contestata"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#victoria"},"kind":"status","status":"established"}],"kind":"and"},"contentHash":"sha256:8d571c8c525af0604a7db88cf21f9bf2eb64bc1695e4c13408ff838e935da69a","head":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#SententiaeParere","kind":"norm_template_ref"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#SententiaeParendum","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"quod ex sententia debetur, solvendum est"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"проигравший обязан исполнить присуждённое приговором"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14"],"contentHash":"sha256:41edfc3988f30da7e2ac9fd9f63c9ebbb14c6dba0e68cfcb3dc245291aace9f0","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#SententiaeParere","kind":"norm_template","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"quod ex sententia debetur, solvendum est"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"проигравший обязан исполнить присуждённое приговором"}],"modality":"duty","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","payload":{"bearer":{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},"beneficiary":{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},"goal":{"condition":{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#sententiae_satisfactum"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},"kind":"achievement","window":{"end":{"kind":"value","type":{"name":"urn:law:std#Text"},"value":"infinity"},"endInclusive":false,"kind":"interval","start":{"kind":"value","type":{"name":"urn:law:std#Date"},"value":"0001-01-01"},"startInclusive":true}},"kind":"duty"}},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10"],"body":{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pronuntiatum_pro"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},"contentHash":"sha256:dbc5c74d3cdf430955064a730be8b0adfc829105b5f5e66153b9a634e3af2a5d","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#victoria"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#VictoriaIudicata","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"sive contra te pronuntiatum erit sive pro te"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"победа в тяжбе устанавливается приговором судей"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_1"],"body":{"formula":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#argumentum_reciprocum"},"kind":"status","status":"established"},"contentHash":"sha256:0f266df18bd56402dae607a2d4ff43889f66dcfc34620cfff334c805da6855d5","head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#vitium_maximum"},"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#VitiumMaximum","interpretations":[],"kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"inter vitia argumentorum longe maximum esse vitium videtur, quae antistrephonta Graeci dicunt"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"оборачиваемость — наибольший из пороков довода"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","scope":{"kind":"boolean","value":true},"strength":"strict","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Argumentum"}}]},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_2","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_3"],"contentHash":"sha256:0408689fdadb27bcf904db45548bea389d66bd0c42ad52f147dcc26ad1d99a4e","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#argumentum_reciprocum","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"argumentum reciprocum sive antistrephon"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"оборачиваемый довод (антистрефон, «reciprocum»)"}],"name":"argumentum_reciprocum","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#argumentum_reciprocum/arg/a","name":"a","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Argumentum"}}],"relationKind":"institutional","symbolKind":"relation"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_5"],"contentHash":"sha256:270672140c7e5bbb0c55e3b5537a6953f0f8428c084d2a57c38cb472bd5555ac","evidence":[],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#assert-1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#EVATHLUS","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#eloquentiae_discendae_cupidus"},"origin":"source_asserted","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_6"],"contentHash":"sha256:832bd96b6cabdcda3681b5991ca7447fa896e665d361d75e43927471e9df0879","evidence":[],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#assert-2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#EVATHLUS","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PROTAGORAS","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#in_disciplinam_dedit"},"origin":"source_asserted","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_6"],"contentHash":"sha256:6ff1bf5d0d84a7e8601bd9ac68640b817fcf9533d7e0ca93906ea30d3ba54a15","evidence":[],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#assert-3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PROTAGORAS","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#EVATHLUS","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PACTUM_MERCEDIS","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pactum_mercedis"},"origin":"source_asserted","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_6"],"contentHash":"sha256:50b8ea47369c232310159a9a34d120329e07366a4d659a9e87f8125eb43130b1","evidence":[],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#assert-4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PACTUM_MERCEDIS","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#dimidium_datum"},"origin":"source_asserted","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_7"],"contentHash":"sha256:4f0a6bba1ba7f3aff5b9ba7b8a1d8e4fc12606f4ec35aa43192dd06d72a9872c","evidence":[],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#assert-5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#EVATHLUS","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causas_non_recepit"},"origin":"source_asserted","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_11"],"contentHash":"sha256:99affdab53d2760f65b06e0a9a4efae53c45dfcabab9e0463552c5105a06e53b","evidence":[],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#assert-6","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#EVATHLUS","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ipse_verba_fecit"},"origin":"source_asserted","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_12"],"contentHash":"sha256:c24e1d60612b9d1949f4b630ae0c9b8d8b5dd13a1200663525370fd284a1e3d1","evidence":[],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#assert-7","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#EVATHLUS","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PROTAGORAS","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#in_argumento_vicit"},"origin":"source_asserted","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9"],"contentHash":"sha256:06dddb4e5dfa98813a92c1896313aea7f5d31c718fabfcf5dbed2b9b2083419d","evidence":[],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#assert-8","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ARGUMENTUM_PROTAGORAE","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#PROTAGORAS","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#dictum_ab"},"origin":"source_asserted","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_13"],"contentHash":"sha256:6c11bf78300596f5fa8a47caac6ff83bbc1a57b0fe4864164f4202e5d77eb05b","evidence":[],"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#assert-9","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ARGUMENTUM_EVATHLI","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#EVATHLUS","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#dictum_ab"},"origin":"source_asserted","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:81acbf42e7ad8343e6f37c9ad28230ba01f78bd60b93145efc1b96db64d4f1ad","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#attempted_transition","kind":"symbol_decl","name":"attempted_transition","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#attempted_transition/arg/instance","name":"instance","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#attempted_transition/arg/transition","name":"transition","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaTransition"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:bf9bfcc846e4f5d6883bcfe168983bb86d4ddd769b7d8ce0cad763e92989de53","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causa_acta_apud_iudices","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"ad iudices coniciendae consistendaeque causae gratia venerunt"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"стороны явились к судьям и дело слушалось"}],"name":"causa_acta_apud_iudices","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causa_acta_apud_iudices/arg/l","name":"l","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:f43ad1418ba5500af14570889073e75cb32889ab1b0ce39ff9fa32bb793bfdb1","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causa_prima","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"haec causa prima eius est"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"эта тяжба у него первая"}],"name":"causa_prima","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causa_prima/arg/orator","name":"orator","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causa_prima/arg/l","name":"l","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:97dd3c6e26b58e02c6506414ca74f2165c207d7981b2399aae6e2b659ca421a5","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causam_oravit","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"causam apud iudices oravit — ipse verba fecit"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"сам произнёс дело перед судьями"}],"name":"causam_oravit","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causam_oravit/arg/orator","name":"orator","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causam_oravit/arg/l","name":"l","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:04b8c9b077407888baef55189bd33333c851df4aa554ffcde06da681fd2bfebf","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causas_non_recepit","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"causas non recipit"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"дел не принимает"}],"name":"causas_non_recepit","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#causas_non_recepit/arg/discipulus","name":"discipulus","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:452396e0381ee77235f7ee537af05c0e7abcbe7eba3eaf756f6f7bb2b3ef15a7","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#converti_potest_in_auctorem","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"referri contra convertique in eum potest, a quo dictum est"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"довод может быть обращён против того, кто его высказал"}],"name":"converti_potest_in_auctorem","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#converti_potest_in_auctorem/arg/a","name":"a","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Argumentum"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:25e834528e0be76433c12f2d9f8b3c3aa1a789e138a70002864583e663fcf1bf","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#dictum_ab","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"argumentum ab eo dictum est"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"довод высказан этим лицом"}],"name":"dictum_ab","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#dictum_ab/arg/a","name":"a","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Argumentum"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#dictum_ab/arg/auctor","name":"auctor","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:47fde4a0916d805b42358f87f126cf5ce82de694bf17a4f708f3cba052a8e376","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#dimidium_datum","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"dimidium eius dedit iam tunc statim, priusquam disceret"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"половина отдана сразу, ещё до обучения"}],"name":"dimidium_datum","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#dimidium_datum/arg/p","name":"p","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Pactum"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:f6a04f714990e188ffe8d291471bf0c023ba8b2a39a33664530fa51698f1828a","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#eloquentiae_discendae_cupidus","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"eloquentiae discendae causarumque orandi cupiens"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"желающий учиться красноречию и вести дела"}],"name":"eloquentiae_discendae_cupidus","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#eloquentiae_discendae_cupidus/arg/p","name":"p","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:4d3a70cc385a66325b00f0052fa9bafaf805f7ef2440e9c167bb0afb88c8a63a","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state","kind":"symbol_decl","name":"entered_state","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state/arg/instance","name":"instance","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#entered_state/arg/state","name":"state","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaState"}}],"relationKind":"institutional","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:cb5b6fe312fb691dccdb3d8960cad25b3317e70908034ba15753a8aea01cedd0","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#in_argumento_vicit","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"te non in causa tantum, sed in argumento quoque isto vinco"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"побеждает не только в деле, но и в самом доводе"}],"name":"in_argumento_vicit","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#in_argumento_vicit/arg/victor","name":"victor","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#in_argumento_vicit/arg/victus","name":"victus","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:3ad395b49f2720fd15f5d6487250f02ed3808e1199ec30779dd5af66a923b097","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#in_disciplinam_dedit","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"in disciplinam sese dedit"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"отдал себя в обучение"}],"name":"in_disciplinam_dedit","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#in_disciplinam_dedit/arg/discipulus","name":"discipulus","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#in_disciplinam_dedit/arg/magister","name":"magister","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:425966e1d3d40697e18cffb57d351cb080ebc08613a2e3691f2ad855121342e8","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ipse_verba_fecit","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"ipse verba fecit, alio patrono non usus est"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"говорил сам, другого защитника не брал"}],"name":"ipse_verba_fecit","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ipse_verba_fecit/arg/p","name":"p","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_4","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8"],"contentHash":"sha256:68f11e5565109768f8306f1eb9377bbeb87fa9ec7b1236885bfb8a9b704e7f61","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_contestata","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"litem contestatur: petere institit ex pacto mercedem"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"иск предъявлен: истец против ответчика"}],"name":"lis_contestata","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_contestata/arg/actor","name":"actor","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_contestata/arg/reus","name":"reus","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_contestata/arg/l","name":"l","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"relationKind":"institutional","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:8de0b7f6c8c9361301e3f201ff9731545c25d34d8424cba72cae08dbec65bfdd","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_prior","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"lis prior iudicata est antequam posterior contestaretur"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"тяжба prior была рассужена ДО того, как предъявлена posterior"}],"name":"lis_prior","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_prior/arg/prior","name":"prior","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#lis_prior/arg/posterior","name":"posterior","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:ff8856ddfdd7ef745e7dfbc62eb8bfef80749946ad6052bd0a3dd237c0548d55","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_debetur","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"merces debetur"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"плата причитается"}],"name":"merces_debetur","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_debetur/arg/debitor","name":"debitor","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_debetur/arg/creditor","name":"creditor","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}}],"relationKind":"institutional","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:4a40adedb782e11fbfbed390c4cbf7976f5b52fc08b674e918a44dbc55c9df4b","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_reliqua_soluta","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"relicum dimidium mercedis solutum est"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"остальная половина платы уплачена"}],"name":"merces_reliqua_soluta","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#merces_reliqua_soluta/arg/p","name":"p","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Pactum"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:6f89731fa5b0d9a42d85ec3a967453a4b06d940edff67691cc34d9d968d4c9d0","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pactum_mercedis","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"pepigit de mercede: dimidium statim, relicum post primam victoriam"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"заключён договор о плате: половина сразу, остаток — после первой победы"}],"name":"pactum_mercedis","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pactum_mercedis/arg/magister","name":"magister","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pactum_mercedis/arg/discipulus","name":"discipulus","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pactum_mercedis/arg/p","name":"p","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Pactum"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:943ab580c45ed37917a2cee47f0e6968b6ba7a050e3ac6d06c21e10d78ac8020","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#procedure_instance","kind":"symbol_decl","name":"procedure_instance","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#procedure_instance/arg/instance","name":"instance","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9"],"contentHash":"sha256:0ca77b95d92b320996077456e82868356aa7a50b5568f1403d17d184053af0d1","effect":"judgment","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pronuntiatum_pro","judgment":{"authority":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Iudices","requestSchema":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#SententiaPetitio"}},"kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"secundum eum iudicatum est — iudicibus statuendum"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"решено в его пользу; устанавливают судьи"}],"name":"pronuntiatum_pro","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pronuntiatum_pro/arg/p","name":"p","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pronuntiatum_pro/arg/l","name":"l","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"relationKind":"judgment","symbolKind":"relation"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9"],"authority":{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Iudices","kind":"const_ref"},"capability":"judgment:Iudices","contentHash":"sha256:227d3a78a7314b18b2ff68c6dc86759e72c7a8921fc433689eaa657961c17c8d","effect":"judgment","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pronuntiatum_pro/external","kind":"external_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"secundum eum iudicatum est — iudicibus statuendum"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"решено в его пользу; устанавливают судьи"}],"package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","requestType":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#SententiaPetitio"},"symbol":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#pronuntiatum_pro"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:280ead5d4fdc073f975fb6be6d7e6c971edca33b229cc5fcf3d4c3568bc442e6","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#res_iniudicata_relicta","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"rem iniudicatam reliquerunt causamque in diem longissimam distulerunt"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"дело оставлено нерассуженным и отложено на долгий срок"}],"name":"res_iniudicata_relicta","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#res_iniudicata_relicta/arg/l","name":"l","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"relationKind":"institutional","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:162a9e8936eeb308e7c5751c1208000c22f2404763348362a70087902fb847c0","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#sententiae_satisfactum","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"sententiae satisfactum est"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"приговор исполнен"}],"name":"sententiae_satisfactum","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#sententiae_satisfactum/arg/l","name":"l","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:8cd1b108e212bb695b3ddf7db50ba96b2afaff9d90020f9be7eac67580605dad","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#suo_argumento_confutatus","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"suo sibi argumento confutatus est"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"опровергнут собственным доводом"}],"name":"suo_argumento_confutatus","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#suo_argumento_confutatus/arg/auctor","name":"auctor","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}}],"relationKind":"institutional","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:8236e5fa7d983e62ae9466e1149de0dd41409fc41c64cd4383d6c02d1dbdfb6b","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#utrimque_pariter_valet","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"utrimque pariter valet"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"довод стоит одинаково сильно с обеих сторон"}],"name":"utrimque_pariter_valet","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#utrimque_pariter_valet/arg/a","name":"a","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Argumentum"}}],"relationKind":"empirical","symbolKind":"relation"},{"anchors":["urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_8","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_9","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_10","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_14","urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#NA_V_10_15"],"contentHash":"sha256:5bc9c40fec2b6678d1857723821a8b6f4fcbb9c72d1d202153acfc490761d24d","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#valid_transition","kind":"symbol_decl","name":"valid_transition","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#valid_transition/arg/instance","name":"instance","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#valid_transition/arg/transition","name":"transition","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#ControversiaTransition"}}],"relationKind":"institutional","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:2354c4dff1258420a416081b1138520a3350ee9613deaa8e4f713cb184c01252","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#vicit_primam_causam","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"primo die causam apud iudices oravit et vicit"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"произнёс дело перед судьями в первой своей тяжбе и выиграл её"}],"name":"vicit_primam_causam","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#vicit_primam_causam/arg/orator","name":"orator","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#vicit_primam_causam/arg/l","name":"l","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"relationKind":"institutional","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:3cfae5c0419606234463e6f35091c6d7c36326001136599a922b639f042cde39","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#victoria","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"vicit in ea lite"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"выиграл эту тяжбу"}],"name":"victoria","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#victoria/arg/victor","name":"victor","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Persona"}},{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#victoria/arg/l","name":"l","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Lis"}}],"relationKind":"institutional","symbolKind":"relation"},{"contentHash":"sha256:c2049c953a1e5acf3846c1f42a00d363a03e4d72430a6c8c0f4ed20a9ca4b42a","id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#vitium_maximum","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"la","status":"official","text":"inter vitia argumentorum longe maximum vitium"},{"language":"ru","status":"unofficial","text":"наибольший из пороков довода"}],"name":"vitium_maximum","package":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","parameters":[{"id":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#vitium_maximum/arg/a","name":"a","type":{"name":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus#Argumentum"}}],"relationKind":"institutional","symbolKind":"relation"}],"package":{"name":"la.gellius.protagoras_euathlus","namespace":"urn:la:gellius:clir:protagoras_euathlus","semanticHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","version":"0.1.0"},"schemaVersion":"law.core.ir/0.2","semanticHash":"sha256:49b7d01599d09282fa850268dcdf1fa568f532b7f614fff89bc0ef73caa19252","semanticVersion":"0.1.0","strata":[]}